PtG Comment 03.04.2020

IOC President holds on to power while federations face financial problems

ANALYSIS: Investigative reporter Jens Weinreich discloses how IOC President Thomas Bach manages the crisis around the Tokyo Games. Criticism is stifled and there is no financial plan for sports federations affected by the postponement.

Decisions come thick and fast in these unique weeks. Exactly two weeks ago I argued that there will of course be no Olympics Games in Tokyo in 2020. This statement was neither prophetic nor particularly original. It was primarily based on common sense and an analysis of the dramatic situation in the midst of a global pandemic. Large parts of the world were already standing still.

At that point, however, the International Olympic Committee (IOC) saw no need to act promptly. 

On 22 March, after one of the Executive Board's conference calls, the IOC announced in a terrifyingly cold tone: "The IOC EB emphasised that a cancellation of the Olympic Games Tokyo 2020 would not solve any of the problems or help anybody. Therefore, cancellation is not on the agenda."

 The term "pandemic" did not appear in the statement. The IOC only spoke of "new outbreaks of COVID-19 in different countries on different continents". Once again, no mention was made of Italy, the host of the 2026 Winter Olympics with the Lombardy and Milan.

In this statement of 22 March, the athletes who had called for "humanity" and early action with their many public statements were not mentioned as the stakeholders with whom the IOC immediately wanted to enter into negotiations on emergency scenarios.

However, IOC President Thomas Bach published a letter to “the global athlete community” at the same time. In it he claimed: "In this unprecedented crisis we are all united."

The opposite was the case.

Two days later, on 24 March, this IOC crisis timetable was scrapped again. The summer Games were suddenly moved to 2021. So suddenly that the Executive Board only voted on it when the move had already been announced live on television by Japan's Prime Minister Shinzo Abe.

And again the IOC gave itself an absurd time frame. The new date of the Games would be announced within three weeks. But again, the IOC was forced to act. The dates were announced only six days later: the Olympic Games 2020 are to be held from 23 July to 8 August 2021. The Paralympics are scheduled to take place from 24 August to 5 September 5 2021.

If the corona pandemic is defeated by then.

A single narrative: Tokyo is a beacon of hope

The IOC leadership has made an increasing effort to control the narrative. One message has been sold on all channels since March 24: "Tokyo could stand as a beacon of hope to the world during these troubled times and the Olympic flame could become the light at the end of the tunnel in which the world finds itself at present."

These buzzwords - flame, hope, end of the tunnel - have been spread by Bach, his propaganda department, the IOC business partners from TV stations and the usual spin doctors 24/7 since then. Garnished with messages of the unity of the Olympic movement. Unity is everything. This is otherwise only known from totalitarian regimes.

The critic who did not want to be a critic

That is the best description of the practices under IOC President Thomas Bach. It becomes absurd when one of the few who had expressed timid criticism in telephone and video conferences with the IOC President later denies having expressed criticism at all.

The story concerns Frenchman David Lappertient, president of the Union Cycliste Internationale (UCI). My sources, who all took part in the call, told me about Lappartient's comments on 26 March during the first post-game conference call.

Lappartient is said to have recalled that Bach had called for the solidarity of the professional federations on 17 March 17 but had failed to show solidarity himself, because the federations were presented with a fait accompli a week later. From my point of view, and from the point of view of my sources, this can certainly be described as a cautious criticism of the IOC President. That's how I described it in an article for the German magazine DER SPIEGEL.

 Some days after publication I received a statement from the UCI. It says:"The UCI President would like to make it clear that he made no comment of the kind, either during the meeting of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) or in any other context. Mr Lappartient spoke during the video conference to call for International Federations to be united around the IOC and its President Thomas Bach. Mr Lappartient, on behalf of the UCI, clearly supports the measures taken by the IOC."

My sources laugh about this statement and stick to their narrative, which I have truthfully reported.

It's worth to take a moment to think about what this UCI message means.

Above all, it means that the only federation president who voiced something like a critical comment to Bach during the conference call does not want to be called a critic. Instead, he preaches the unity of the movement.

It is, I am sorry to say, a bit like a sect.

In the hour of great need, all family members gather behind their unique, great and wise leader.

No plan to help affected Olympic sports federations

It's all about money.

This is very important:

As of December 31, 2018, the IOC had stashed reserves in the amount of approximately $ 900 million in its Olympic Foundation. Perhaps there are even more at the moment, the annual report for 2019 is not yet available.

However, the IOC has so far not set up an aid fund for affected Olympic sports federations (33 in summer, 7 in winter) or the 206 National Olympic Committees (NOC).

They don't even talk about it. Unlike the world football association FIFA, for example, which is planning such a fund, as Tariq Panja has reported in the New York Times.

The IOC continues to find no words of sympathy for the tragedy in the Olympic host country Italy - let alone an aid fund is being created for Italy.

The IOC merely stated that the Olympic Solidarity programme continued to support athletes and NOC programs as before.

The IOC has so far not made any offers for funding to the federations in the programme of the Tokyo Games, the 28 permanent and the 5 guest sports.

Major problems if television revenues are delayed

The 28 permanent summer sports federations and their umbrella organisation ASOIF are entitled to US $ 590 million from the worldwide Olympic marketing revenues for Tokyo. Such payments are always made after the Games have taken place - after the IOC has collected the majority of the billion-dollar television revenue.

Basically, the federations will finance their operations in the next Olympic cycle from 2021 to 2024 with this money until the next big transfer will be made after the Paris Games in autumn 2024. After the 2016 Games in Rio de Janeiro, $ 540 million were distributed, and federations used that money to finance themselves for the period from 2017 to 2020.

If the shares from television revenues do not arrive before autumn 2021 with a one-year delay, many associations face major problems. Especially since another consequence of the corona pandemic is that federations will lose parts of their own income from sponsorship and TV contracts. 

IOC does not want to give all federations an advance

It would have been the most normal thing in the world, if Thomas Bach had told the federations: We will pay you 25 percent in advance from the Olympic revenues - from your Olympic revenues - so you can survive the next year.

He didn't do that. Instead, it is said that bilateral negotiations are now underway.

A member of the Executive Board explained this to me confidentially: "If the President had offered everyone an advance, those federations that did not need the money urgently would also have held their hand out for money.”

But what this influential IOC member forgets in the process: The $ 590 million are not really IOC property - the money is the rightful share of the summer sports federations. Neither the IOC nor Japan can host the Olympic Games without the federations..

Several federation presidents have explained to me that Thomas Bach is now playing out his power by not offering help and an advance payment on his own initiative.

"That he doesn't do this is a signal," says a president. "He shows that you have to approach him and ask him for something. Requests are of course only granted if they follow the rules."

The service requested in return? Unity. Unconditional unity. No contradiction. Subordination.

That's how it works in the Olympic family.

The art of Macciavelli.

Bach strengthens his power base before elections

Bach has another means of pressure: negotiations are already underway as to what share the federations will be paid from the Olympic marketing program for 2021 to 2024. Of course, the associations want more. Perhaps $ 650 million, maybe even $ 700 million.

Such negotiations have been bitter for decades, starting when the first little TV revenue was generated in the 1960s. These negotiations and the share between IOC and the international federations and even among the international federations is the most difficult sports-political science. It is more or less an attempt to square the circle.

In this respect, Thomas Bach - quite a power politician - still profits from the crisis and a difficult situation. He can curb timid criticism among the associations. The top officials, presidents and general directors are lined up behind him. After the IOC acted far too late, Bach sold himself as a terrific crisis manager and strengthened his position again. Nobody can fool him. Challengers are not in sight anyway.

So if the 2021 Olympic Games can be held, the IOC will sell these Games as humanity's victory against the corona virus. Their absurd spin is: The Olympic fire showed the way out of the dark tunnel. So they want to benefit from the corona crisis in many ways.

And, don’t forget, next year there will be elections in the IOC. Bach, who became president in 2013, wants to be elected for another four years.

Read more 

Read more by Jens Weinreich about the IOC  and the Olympic Games in Tokyo:

Related articles

Sebastian Coe greets winner
PtG Article 14.05.2024
Money for medals divides the Olympic movement
Whitney Bragnolo at Play the Game conference
PtG Article 23.02.2024
Sports federations urged to do more to safeguard athletes
Kristin Kloster
PtG Article 16.02.2024
IOC member: No Taliban flag at the Olympics in Paris
PtG Comment 27.03.2023
Coe and Bach: United in history, divided by history
Olympic rings
PtG Article 02.02.2023
A thought experiment: Estimating global sports’ total carbon emissions
Ivo Ferriani and Thomas Bach
PtG Article 18.11.2022
World sports federations may give up their own independent platform
Mehboba Ahdyar
PtG Article 20.09.2022
New IOC human rights strategy brought to the test in negotiations with the Taliban regime
Panel at Play the Game 2022.
PtG Article 27.06.2022
Russian sanctions unlikely to herald a new era of accountability
Stanislav Pozdnyakov
PtG Article 05.04.2022
Most Olympic federations suspend Russian athletes, but officials go free
Thomas Bach and Vladimir Putin
PtG Comment 02.03.2022
The coalition of Olympic perpetrators
Kamilia Valieva
PtG Comment 22.02.2022
Child athletes are too valuable for the Olympic system to set age limits
Beijing 2022 opening ceremony
PtG Comment 08.02.2022
A modest but confident China on display at the 2022 Beijing Olympics opening ceremony
PtG Comment 19.01.2022
The political power of the Olympic opening ceremony: Lessons from Beijing and Sochi
Uyghurs demonstrate in Washington
PtG Article 14.10.2021
Beijing 2022: Olympic boycott battle over China’s ‘Genocide Games’
Sheikh Ahmad Al-Fahad Al-Sabah
PtG Comment 06.10.2021
One coup too many: Olympic powerbroker sentenced to prison
PtG Comment 19.05.2021
Beijing 2022: To the moon and back
Thomas Bach - photo by milos bicanski
PtG Comment 10.03.2021
The playbook that keeps Thomas Bach in power at the IOC
Construction workers
PtG Comment 23.02.2021
The unpredictable financial costs of hosting the Olympic Games
Alexander Lukashenko
PtG Comment 15.12.2020
Olympic finger-wagging at Europe’s last dictator
Tamas Ajan
PtG Article 12.11.2020
FBI and Swiss police dig into weightlifting scandal, while IOC is undecided
Photo by IOC/Ian Jones
PtG Comment 09.11.2020
To stand up for Olympic values it may be necessary to kneel as well
Protests in Belarus
PtG Article 23.10.2020
Belarusian athletes take lead in battle for democracy
Nikki Dryden
PtG Comment 21.08.2020
Athletes should not be gagged in exchange for Olympic dream
Megan Rapinoe
PtG Comment 23.06.2020
Making a case for athlete advocacy: Humanitarians, Olympism and good governance
Naoko Imoto received the Olympic torch
PtG Comment 11.05.2020
A leaked list discloses how much cash the IOC paid for the 2016 Olympics in Rio
Alisher Usmanov and Thomas Bach
PtG Article 03.04.2020
How federations share the revenues from the Olympic Games
Tokyo 2020 sign
PtG Comment 20.03.2020
Growing pressure as the IOC and Japan play for time
Men raising their fists
PtG Comment 11.02.2020
A fist of freedom or a fist of iron? Rule 50 and the Olympic paradox
People protesting the olympics
PtG Comment 03.12.2019
NOlympics Anywhere: A transnational movement to stop the Olympic Games is gathering strength
Naomi Osaka
PtG Article 08.11.2019
Mixed-blood athletes challenge old myths in Japan
Thomas Bach
PtG Article 05.11.2019
IOC-President calls for sanctions of athletes’ entourage
PtG Comment 16.10.2019
Open letter to IOC President Thomas Bach from athlete organisations
PtG Article 03.07.2019
Scandals expose widespread harassment in Japanese sport before the Olympics
PtG Comment 07.11.2018
Opposition to the Olympics in American cities
PtG Comment 24.10.2018
Hamburg’s bid for the 2024 Games: Political misconceptions of citizens’ concerns
PtG Comment 08.10.2018
A cautious game: Protesting mega-events in Russia
PtG Comment 08.10.2018
Civil society, contestation, and the games
PtG Comment 28.02.2018
Jean-Marie Weber, the biggest bag man in Olympic history
Olympic stadium seen from the air
PtG Comment 18.12.2015
Permanent host cities – a sustainable future for the Olympic Games
Bobsleigh at Sochi 2014
PtG Comment 19.11.2015
After Sochi 2014: Costs and impacts of Russia’s Olympic Games