PtG Article 15.04.2019

Journalists investigating sports corruption exposed to many kinds of risks

For some journalists, reporting on integrity breaches in sport comes at a price, says this paper and presents various dangers that sports journalists face. The paper is commissioned by EPAS as part of their work with UNESCO’s Kazan Action Plan.

This paper was commissioned by the Enlarged Partial Agreement on Sport (EPAS) under the Council of Europe as part of its work for UNESCO’s Kazan Action Plan in the field of integrity of sport.

(Updated 23 April 2019)

The role of journalism in detecting breaches of integrity in sport

When British investigative journalist, Andrew Jennings, began investigating the International Olympic Committee (IOC) in the early 1990's, some of his colleagues made fun of him for looking at what they thought to be an unimportant area of public life. Writing for the International Review for the Sociology of Sport, he recalls his own reply: "Sports organisations are in the public sphere. They're backed by public money. They wield power. Why should they escape scrutiny?"

Despite the diligent work of Andrew Jennings to uncover the corruption at the heart of the IOC and later the International Football Federation, FIFA, the fact is that the vast majority of media coverage of sports does not contain much scrutiny.

The International Sports Press Survey produced for Play the Game in 2011 showed that newspaper coverage in 22 countries focused almost exclusively on sports performances in the form of match reports, comments on performances and previews of upcoming competitions and matches.

Journalists rely on athletes, coaches and representatives from sports organisations to produce their stories, and access to these sources are often carefully managed by sports organisations. This reliance has lead to increasing commercialisation of sports news where journalists agree to mention sponsors or advertisers to get interviews, and it has also promoted self-censorship as journalists fear being cut off from key sources if they are too critical.

The watchdogs of sport are mainly investigative journalists

The task of uncovering that which some stakeholders in sport would prefer to be kept in the dark mainly falls to an increasingly smaller group of investigative journalists - many of whom are independent freelance journalists without the support and protection of a larger media organisation.

They painstakingly put together their own stories but some also work on unravelling the stories hidden in documents and information leaked by whistleblowers. That was the case in 2014 when a senior figure inside FIFA leaked millions of documents to The Sunday Times.

These so-called FIFA Files lead to a series of articles that showed how Mohamad bin Hammam, Quatar's top football oficial, had masterminded a plot to buy the 2022 World Cup for Qatar.

In 2016, more than 60 journalists working for media in 12 different countries partnered within the framework of the European Investigative Collaborations and began publishing stories based on the largest leak of documents in the history of sport. The Football Leaks have revealed corruption among top officials, clubs, agents and players in many different countries, and the stories continue to be unearthed and published. Corruption is one way of breaching the integrity in sport, but journalists continuously uncover breaches in other areas too:

  • In 2008, Canadian investigative journalist, Declan Hill, published his book "The Fix: Soccer and Organized Crime" that details the methods and motives of match-fixers in football. According to Hill, the book has helped spark over thirty national police investigations, and the author has also testified about his findings before the International Olympic Committee,  the Council of Europa and numerous national sports agencies.
  • In 2014, German investigative journalist Hajo Seppelt's documentary "Doping Top Secret: How Russia makes its winners" was broadcast on ARD and presented evidence of state sponsored systematic doping in athletics and other sports in Russia. The documentary led several figures in international sports organisations and anti-doping institutions to eitherresign their posts or being suspended. In June 2016, a follow-up documentary led the International Association of Athletics Federation to extend its suspension of its Russian Association and almost all Russian athletes were not allowed to take part in the Olympic Games 2016.
  • In 2016, the local US newspaper Indianapolis Star's investigative team uncovered sexual abuse within USA Gymnastics believed to have affected more than 150 young girls including Olympic champion Simone Biles. Team doctor, Larry Nasser, was later sentenced to 175 years in prison for sexual assualt, the board of USA Gymnastics was reorganised, and  the US Olympic Committee announced changes to its policy for reporting abuse. 

The dangers of sports journalism

Reporting on sports comes at a price for some journalists. In 2017, an academic study published in the book 'The Assault on Journalism' showed that sports journalists regularly are subjected to violations of media freedom and personal safety.

Analysing 78 reports in the public domain about incidents that took place between 2010 and 2016, the study documented that sports journalists have been banned from press conferences, stadiums or events, and some have had their passports seized or been denied accredition when trying to enter a country to cover a sports event. The personal safety of sports journalist was compromised through arrests and detentions; physical and verbal assaults; abduction; attacks; physical, verbal and digital threats of violence or death; legal actions; damage to property; personal and digital sexual abuse; and killings.

For instance, Andrew Jennings has been banned from attending press conferences at the IOC and FIFA; Hajo Seppelt received so many death threats for his work on doping in Russia that ARD had to hire security personel to protect him and his colleagues; and a Spanish judge issued an injunction ordering the 12 European media organisations to stop publishing revelations from the Football Leaks.

Media organsiations and journalists are integral parts of a sports world fuelled by strong eco­nomic interests and high emotions, where a wide range of stakeholders are monitoring and trying to affect how journalists cover issues dear to them.

The high number of stakeholders is a key feature of this specific subfield of safety of journalists where perpetrators of violations against sports journalists include such different groups as sports fans, athletes and coaches, owners and officials of sports clubs and associations, and international sports federations. Police and political authorities also feature prominently on the list particularly in relation to mega-events. Even the Islamic terrorist group Al-Shabaab in Somalia has been targeting and killing sports journalists for glorifying what the group calls "satanic sports".

Considering the wide range of stakeholders in sport as well as the current low level of research and understanding of the threats faced by journalists uncovering breaches of integrity in the world of sport, it is difficult to identify specific challenges that should be overcome to ensure that journalists can continue to act as watchdogs in this particular part of the public sphere.

More research is needed to determine the exact nature of the problems, their extent, their impact, how they should be handled, and who should be involved in pro­tecting sports journalists from harm or (self)-censorship. It is an important first step to acknowledge that the problems exist. The next step would be to build mechanisms that ensure that sports journalists are encouraged to report the violations they experience in order to inform the search for solutions.

More information

This paper, which has been slightly customised for online publishing in agreement with the author, was prepared by Kirsten Sparre, Journalist, MA, Ph.D and Assistant Professor at the Danish School of Media and Journalism & Department of Media Studies and Journalism at Aarhus University, Denmark.
See also Kirsten Sparre's presentation from Play the Game 2017 in which she presents some of her research into the dangers of sports journalism.
Download the book 'The Assault on Journalism' for free. Kirsten Sparre has contributed with the chapter 'The Dangers of Sports Journalism'.

Related news

Speaker
PtG Comment 27.06.2022
Sport must choose between democracy and autocracy
Andrew Jennings
PtG Article 24.03.2022
'Sport & Politics’ publishes a special magazine about Andrew Jennings
Andrew Jennings on podium
PtG Article 10.01.2022
Andrew Jennings (1943-2022), the incomparable
PtG Article 17.12.2021
With the old guard down the rabbit hole
Sheikh Ahmad Al-Fahad Al-Sabah
PtG Comment 06.10.2021
One coup too many: Olympic powerbroker sentenced to prison
Ary Graca
PtG Article 09.07.2021
World’s volleyball president at risk of losing his impunity
Tamas Ajan
PtG Article 12.11.2020
FBI and Swiss police dig into weightlifting scandal, while IOC is undecided
PtG Article 12.11.2020
Weightlifting: When cleaners come with dirty hands
Bonita Mersiades
PtG Article 09.08.2020
Australian football executives sue FIFA whistleblower
Tamas Ajan
PtG Article 09.06.2020
The man who blew the whistle on his own corruption
Gianni infantino visiting South Sudan
PtG Comment 28.05.2020
FBI vs. FIFA: How deep an impact?
Sports fans
PtG Comment 28.04.2020
Coronavirus, connection and (no) sport
Stadium
PtG Comment 02.03.2020
Football Leaks raises many questions – also for the media
Conference panel
PtG Article 18.12.2019
Governments step up their actions against sports corruption
PtG Comment 28.02.2018
Jean-Marie Weber, the biggest bag man in Olympic history
The Stepanovs and Hajo Seppelt
PtG Article 29.11.2017
The Stepanovs and Hajo Seppelt receive the Play the Game Award
PtG Article 29.11.2017
Dangers of sports journalism
Soccer pitch
PtG Article 07.04.2017
The cheating menace of African refereeing
FIFA sign
PtG Article 07.12.2015
FBI investigates Sepp Blatter through ISL link
Bob Munro and Jens Sejer Andersen
PtG Article 28.10.2015
Bob Munro and Mathare Youth Sports Association receive the Play the Game Award
PtG Comment 03.05.2013
FIFA’s new Ethics Committee fails first test
PtG Article 30.04.2013
Blatter cleared by FIFA ISL examination
PtG Article 04.12.2012
Blatter faces “once in a lifetime opportunity”
Horses racing
PtG Article 10.08.2012
Gangs and corruption in Australian horse racing
PtG Comment 02.04.2012
Pieth’s prudent paper and Blatter’s play for time
PtG Article 02.11.2011
Sums of bribes for top FIFA officials exposed at hearing in Brazil
PtG Article 21.10.2011
FIFA announces reform process against corruption
Jens Weinreich and Andrew Jennings
PtG Article 06.10.2011
Jens Weinreich and Andrew Jennings win 2011 Play the Game Award
Newspaper
PtG Article 03.10.2011
New sports press survey: Newspapers focus narrowly on sports results
PtG Article 30.11.2010
FIFA dismisses BBC corruption claims, IOC prepares investigation
PtG Article 29.11.2010
New revelations: FIFA Executives named as ISL bribe-takers
PtG Article 19.10.2010
The Magicians of Sport: How the Greatest Corruption Scandal in World Sport Vanished Before We Knew It Existed
PtG Article 24.06.2010
Prosecutor's office links FIFA officials to bribery scandal
PtG Article 09.07.2008
Only minor convictions in corruption case against ISL executives
PtG Article 02.05.2008
Indian Hockey Federation suspended after bribery scandal
PtG Article 08.04.2008
ISL embezzlement case closes – verdict expected 2 July 2008
PtG Article 13.03.2008
Swiss judge reveals sport’s largest corruption scandal ever in trial against FIFA partners
Newspapers
PtG Article 05.01.2008
The Dangers of Sports Journalism
PtG Article 27.06.2007
FIFA reorganises before ISL court case opens in March next year
PtG Article 29.09.2006
Swiss magistrate accuses FIFA official of taking bribes