PtG Article 16.10.2019

FIFA governance under renewed assault

Any potential rivals to Gianni Infantino would need a war chest of at least £2 million to successfully challenge the FIFA president in a future election, said the former chairman of FIFA’s Governance and Review Committee at Play the Game 2019.

The former chairman of FIFA’s Governance and Review Committee, Miguel Poiares Maduro, came with a stark warning in his presentation at Play the Game 2019.

“A campaign costs at least £2 million to be president, even if you don’t buy votes,” said Professor Miguel Polares Maduro, who was at FIFA from June 2016 to May 2017.

“It’s not possible to be president of FIFA without spending a few millions and we don’t know where that money comes from.”

Lack of transparency and the ongoing governance crisis at world football’s governing body came under heavy fire from an experienced group of panellists at Play the Game.

Professor Maduro led the charge, insisting that FIFA cannot reform itself due to its culture. “FIFA is dominated by two fundamental problems,” he said. “It is dominated by a political cartel with a high concentration of power and there is no effective independent scrutiny. These two reasons are why FIFA cannot reform itself.”

Professor Maduro from the School of Transnational Governance at the European University Institute gave a number of examples, such as elections involving single candidates.

He explained: “Even with a single candidate, you still need a 50% majority but there could be 50% abstentions. They don’t follow this because it allows them to install members of the political cartel.

“What explains this political cartel is that it’s a closed constituency. What you need to change is the electoral body.”

During his brief tenure, Maduro said that his committee did prevent some unsuitable people getting positions, but he worried that what was achieved was being undone.

Giving an example, he said: “The rule that confederations must elect at least one woman was turned on its head so now confederations cannot elect any more than one woman.”

Infantino was the “fruit from the same tree” as his two predecessors as FIFA president, Joao Havelange and Sepp Blatter, said Maduro.

Old or new FIFA?

Infantino was also the “instrument of dubious interests” said Jan Jensen from Danish newspaper Ekstra Bladet, who, in a joint presentation with Norwegian freelance journalist Andreas Selliaas, looked at the changes in FIFA’s culture and the shift from whitewashing to football washing.

Selliaas said: “The old FIFA was a ‘decentraliser’ with a president who knew about corruption, but tolerated it as long as it was good for him. The new FIFA is more centralised and hands on over who is going to be elected.”

As an example, Selliaas gave FIFA’s installing Fatma Samoura to run the Confederation of African Football directly for the world body, which he described as “unbelievable”. He added: “In football, there are only white elephants and paper tigers.”

The role of football’s political elite was also the subject of a passionate address by Australian activist and whistleblower Bonita Mersiades, who asked what changes there really had been at FIFA.

“When one person departs, another person simply takes over their role,” said Mersiades, who illustrated this by pointing out the succession of indictments placed on senior figures and their replacements in countries and regions such as Brazil, CONCACAF and Oceania.

Any changes were “more about sizzle than substance and the process rather than the culture,” said Mersiades, who added: “FIFA sets the standard at the lowest common denominator as its suits their business. It’s truly a case of the more things change, the more they stay the same.”

Balance to the assault on FIFA was provided by the world federation’s former chief compliance officer, Edward Hanover, who explained how some reforms had been pushed through on a financial level.

The world body distributes $450m a year and the reforms were aimed at introducing compliance systems that tracked money in and out of FIFA.

“We began to audit every year and it was a shock to some of the member associations, but we wanted the organisations to understand how they are spending their money,” said Hanover. “My goal was to limit the own goals.”

FIFA was a “highly political organisation” admitted Hanover, but he added: “Not once in three years was I told don’t look into that. I know people will be surprised by that but that was my experience.”

While some candidates on the panel suggested replacing FIFA with a new world body might be preferable, Hanover said: “If you are going to wait for something to completely start again, you will be waiting a long time.”

Instead, changes to FIFA must come from outside concluded Maduro, who said: “Any attempts to reform FIFA cannot come from within. No cartel opens itself up to competition by definition.”

“Change needs to come from outside and will not come from a state. Any time FIFA is challenged by a state, they can take their revenge by excluding their national teams.”

“There needs to be a transnational effort led by the courts.”

Whether this will materialise before the next Play the Game in 2021 or at all remains to be seen.

Other news from Play the Game 2019

PtG Article 20.02.2020
Massive backing from participants to the first Play the Game conference outside Europe
Erin Willson
PtG Article 25.10.2019
The struggle for safe sport in Canada: one step forward, two steps back
Anas Anas presenting at conference
PtG Article 24.10.2019
Sports betting: What are the odds on a fix?
Nikki Dryden
PtG Article 16.10.2019
Athlete activism: defending the right to protest
Conference speakers
PtG Article 16.10.2019
The great doping battle
Nancy Hogshead-Makar
PtG Article 16.10.2019
Nancy Hogshead-Makar receives the Play the Game Award 2019
PtG Article 16.10.2019
Play the Game 2019 on tour to USOPC training hub
PtG Article 16.10.2019
NCAA must strive to benefit student athletes
PtG Comment 16.10.2019
IAAF shares viewpoints on Semenya after Play the Game 2019 debate
PtG Comment 16.10.2019
Open letter to IOC President Thomas Bach from athlete organisations
PtG Article 15.10.2019
What it means to blow the whistle
PtG Article 15.10.2019
The role of team doctors in professional sport
PtG Article 15.10.2019
Tackling threats to grassroots sport
PtG Article 15.10.2019
Broken Trust premieres at Play the Game 2019
PtG Article 15.10.2019
The U.S. questions how to measure good governance in sport
PtG Article 15.10.2019
Whistleblowing: Minimising the risks
PtG Article 15.10.2019
Doping decisions: In pursuit of uniform sentencing
PtG Article 14.10.2019
Interview with David Howman
PtG Article 14.10.2019
Interview with Linda Helleland
PtG Article 14.10.2019
Athletes must be heard
PtG Article 14.10.2019
Good Governance: Just another buzz phrase?
PtG Article 14.10.2019
Will the Sports Governance Observer bring changes to world sport?
PtG Comment 14.10.2019
New standards of sports governance: When will sport join the modern world in embracing democracy?
PtG Comment 14.10.2019
Good governance – the new sport mantra
PtG Article 13.10.2019
Sport: A safe haven for athletes?
PtG Article 13.10.2019
Interview with Yuliya and Vitaly Stepanov
PtG Article 13.10.2019
Russian whistleblower: “The fight is not over yet”
PtG Article 13.10.2019
Athletes' voices: breakthrough or breakdown?
PtG Article 13.10.2019
Time’s up: Athlete power on the rise!
PtG Comment 13.10.2019
Athlete activism: An omen for sport in the 2020's?
Børn spiller fodbold
PtG Article 08.10.2019
The global challenge of growing sports

Related articles

Viola von Cramon
PtG Article 28.09.2022
Member of European Parliament launches call for a world anti-corruption agency for sport
Panel
PtG Article 04.07.2022
Many nations lack the will and resources to implement governance reforms
Drago Kos at Play the Game 2022
PtG Article 04.07.2022
Play the Game may be the correct forum to develop a sports anti-corruption agency
minister for culture
PtG Comment 30.06.2022
Sportswashing is a deep contradiction of the core values of sport
Panel at conference
PtG Article 29.06.2022
Reports of abuse of athletes continue to emerge across the globe
Presenter
PtG Article 29.06.2022
External oversight key to athlete trust in abuse and violence investigations
Panel at Play the Game 2022.
PtG Article 27.06.2022
Russian sanctions unlikely to herald a new era of accountability
Man presenting at conference
PtG Article 27.06.2022
Saudi Arabia is filling the vacuum after Russia in a year of sportswashing
Speakers
PtG Article 27.06.2022
Play the Game 2022 opens with a call to remove Belarussian sports officials
Photo: GettyImages/Matt Roberts.
PtG Article 10.06.2022
New book presents urgent call to listen to athletes in modern pentathlon
Andrew Jennings
PtG Article 24.03.2022
'Sport & Politics’ publishes a special magazine about Andrew Jennings
Thomas Bach and Vladimir Putin
PtG Comment 02.03.2022
The coalition of Olympic perpetrators
Fans criticising owners of football club
PtG Article 01.02.2022
Few European countries have plans for regulating football club ownership
Hassan Moustafa
PtG Article 24.01.2022
New research: Alternative voting systems may lead to better governance in sport
Andrew Jennings on podium
PtG Article 10.01.2022
Andrew Jennings (1943-2022), the incomparable
PtG Article 17.12.2021
With the old guard down the rabbit hole
PtG Article 09.12.2021
Playing with dictators behind closed doors: Athletes pay the price
Krystsina Tsimanouskaya
PtG Article 30.11.2021
A vote of no confidence in the Court of Arbitration for Sport
PtG Article 26.11.2021
Utrecht University publishes free book on sports governance
Putin and Infantino at a football stadium
PtG Comment 26.11.2021
The work of improving sports governance has just begun
PtG Article 25.11.2021
Head of NOC: Sports federations need more demands from society
Hand over computer keyboard
PtG Article 23.11.2021
Play the Game launches online versions of governance benchmarking tools
Tennis court with balls
PtG Article 23.11.2021
New research: National sports federations still need better governance
CAS building in Lausanne
PtG Article 18.11.2021
The secretive life of the Court of Arbitration for Sport
Kim Andersen
PtG Article 05.11.2021
World Sailing President lost re-election campaign amid ethical complaints: Case dismissed
Sheikh Mansour from Abu Dhabi
PtG Article 27.10.2021
Multi-club ownership in football challenges governance at many levels
Sheikh Ahmad Al-Fahad Al-Sabah
PtG Comment 06.10.2021
One coup too many: Olympic powerbroker sentenced to prison
Ary Graca
PtG Article 09.07.2021
World’s volleyball president at risk of losing his impunity
PtG Article 30.06.2021
New report documents governance standards in anti-doping in 11 countries
Khalida Popal
PtG Article 27.05.2021
Sexual abuse in football: Presidential predators and pedophile child molesters
PtG Comment 10.05.2021
Boycott Qatar: What are the chances?
Danish national football team
PtG Comment 22.04.2021
Athletes knock the legs from under global sports governance
CAF president
PtG Comment 15.04.2021
FIFA’s choice for new president in African football cements crisis in CAF
Megan Rapinoe
PtG Comment 23.06.2020
Making a case for athlete advocacy: Humanitarians, Olympism and good governance
Gianni infantino visiting South Sudan
PtG Comment 28.05.2020
FBI vs. FIFA: How deep an impact?
Sports fans
PtG Comment 28.04.2020
Coronavirus, connection and (no) sport
Football stadium with greek flag
PtG Comment 24.04.2020
Corona: Leaving the current business model of sport offside
Conference panel
PtG Article 18.12.2019
Governments step up their actions against sports corruption
Putin holding the 2018 world cup trophy
PtG Article 29.11.2019
More – not less – democracy is often better for organising a World Cup