PtG Article 14.10.2019

Ten years of testosterone trouble

For a decade, the South African athletics star Caster Semenya has been at the center of a controversy surrounding a high level of testosterone in her body and her right to compete as a female. What does the Semenya case mean to athletes?

In 2009, the Australian 800 meter runner Madeleine Pape participated in the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF)World Championship in Berlin and witnessed a young South African star being born. Caster Semenya was the name of the new world champion in the event and her victory started a controversy surrounding a high level of testosterone in her body and her right to compete as a female that has now lasted for ten years.

“At the time, I was quick to conclude that, sure, maybe I didn’t want Semenya competing in my event. But I knew nothing about the history of sex testing practices in sport, I knew nothing about variation in human sex development, and I was immersed in a sporting culture in which there are no critical reflection on whether this was how we should be treating our new world champion and other women alleged to have variations in their sex development,” Pape said in a session at Play the Games’ conference in Colorado Springs this week, in which the question was asked what the ongoing dispute between Caster Semenya and the IAAF means to athletes.

To Pape, the ten years of testosterone trouble for Semenya and other women in sport meant that she over time changed her position on the issue. After ending her career in 2010 with an injury, the Australian moved to the University of Wisconsin-Madison in the U.S. to pursue a PhD in Sociology, which led her to reflect critically on that period of her life, and ultimately to a position of support for the participation of women with high testosterone in her sport.

“It wasn’t overnight, and it was a journey during which I often felt confronted and conflicted,” she said, pointing out that her change in position was caused by her change in career, an understanding of the biology, and the science surrounding what sex is, how it occurs in our bodies, and how it relates to athletic performance.

“I had moved to a different ideological or cultural environment in which I was exposed to alternative points of views, and perhaps most critically, there was a change in my understanding of the stakes in regulating inclusion in women’s sport, and that happened through becoming friends with women with high testosterone, AND trans women, and realizing that what we do in sport does have broader implications for their ability to live liveable lives, and I wasn’t prepared to tell my friends that, sure, I recognized them as women outside of sport, but I wouldn’t welcome them alongside me on the track.”

Intense scrutiny

At that point, Pape began to ask why she had been so uncritical as an athlete in Berlin in 2009?

“And, particularly in the lead up to the Rio Olympic Games in 2016, where again, Semenya and two other women of color from Sub Saharan Africa were subject to intense scrutiny and accused of having an unfair advantage, I wondered, has the sport changed? How can we make sense of this ongoing controversy?”

As part of her dissertation, Pape conducted 65 interviews with stakeholders involved at the elite level of track and field, including athletes, coaches, media commentators and journalists, officials, and team staff.

First, the research showed a widespread misunderstanding and misinformation surrounding the complexities of sex, the complexities of testosterone and athletic performance, and the complexities of the decisions taken by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) in 2015 when they opted to suspend the IAAF hyperandrogenism regulations at the time.

Second, stakeholder opinions on the legitimacy of regulating women with high testosterone were not driven by science, even though this issue is often framed as a scientific matter.

Third, she found evidence of institutional racism.

And fourth, the research showed a very deep-seated fear of change and the unknown, not only in relation to redefining women’s sport as inclusive of women with high testosterone, but also trans women.

An exclusive approach

“So we have on our hands an ideologically divided sport. What we have in common is that we all want what’s best for women. Where we disagree is on what that looks like, because we are committed to different understandings of what a woman is, and what our strategy should be for pursuing gender equality,” Pape said.

“So what now? How do we get beyond the impasse to depolarize this emotionally charged topic and enable listening, understanding, and respectful dialogue? Can we reimagine women’s participation in a sport in a way that makes room for a more inclusive and expansive definition of the female body? This is an especially pressing question in a social context where the boundaries of sex and gender are shifting, and it is going to become increasingly untenable for organisations like the IAAF to maintain an exclusive approach to female athlete eligibility.”

And to the former Australian athlete, there are many other questions to reflect on:

“What kind of education efforts could be undertaken by the IAAF and the IOC? Women’s sports organisations? LGBTQI organisations? Athlete representative bodies? What are the conditions for enabling more compassionate and considered – and less far driven – discussions about female eligibility? What role should science play and how should it be balanced alongside other considerations, such as disproportionate impact on women of color from Global South nations?”

Four fatal flaws

To many stakeholders in sport, the Semenya case has been an example of IAAF’s wrongdoing towards a strong athlete, who will not give up her right to compete as woman. One of the IAAF critics, the editor of The Sports Integrity Initiative, Andy Brown, also took part in the session:

“I have been following Caster Semenya’s case for over ten years now. Although the IAAF denies it, for ten years it has been calling Caster Semenya a man. Its latest incarnation of this is that Semenya – and all DSD athletes are ‘biologically male’,” Brown said.

And Roger Pielke Jr., a professor at the University of Colorado and an expert witness for Caster Semenya before the CAS in February, said that the IAAF has made four fatal flaws in the case:

“IAAF rewrote the regulations on the eve of the CAS hearing. IAAF used flawed empirical science to establish the restricted categories. IAAF uses flawed theoretical science to reclassify certain females as ‘biologically males’. IAAF regulations require that medical professionals violate widely held guidelines for medical and research ethics.”

The IAAF did not attend the session. But according to Play the Game’s International Director, Jens Sejer Andersen, the IAAF was invited to present its views on the Semenya case at the conference in Colorado Springs.

Other news from Play the Game 2019

PtG Article 20.02.2020
Massive backing from participants to the first Play the Game conference outside Europe
Erin Willson
PtG Article 25.10.2019
The struggle for safe sport in Canada: one step forward, two steps back
Anas Anas presenting at conference
PtG Article 24.10.2019
Sports betting: What are the odds on a fix?
Nikki Dryden
PtG Article 16.10.2019
Athlete activism: defending the right to protest
Conference speakers
PtG Article 16.10.2019
The great doping battle
Nancy Hogshead-Makar
PtG Article 16.10.2019
Nancy Hogshead-Makar receives the Play the Game Award 2019
PtG Article 16.10.2019
Play the Game 2019 on tour to USOPC training hub
PtG Article 16.10.2019
NCAA must strive to benefit student athletes
PtG Comment 16.10.2019
IAAF shares viewpoints on Semenya after Play the Game 2019 debate
PtG Comment 16.10.2019
Open letter to IOC President Thomas Bach from athlete organisations
PtG Article 15.10.2019
What it means to blow the whistle
PtG Article 15.10.2019
The role of team doctors in professional sport
PtG Article 15.10.2019
Tackling threats to grassroots sport
PtG Article 15.10.2019
Broken Trust premieres at Play the Game 2019
PtG Article 15.10.2019
The U.S. questions how to measure good governance in sport
PtG Article 15.10.2019
Whistleblowing: Minimising the risks
PtG Article 15.10.2019
Doping decisions: In pursuit of uniform sentencing
PtG Article 14.10.2019
Interview with David Howman
PtG Article 14.10.2019
Interview with Linda Helleland
PtG Article 14.10.2019
Athletes must be heard
PtG Article 14.10.2019
Good Governance: Just another buzz phrase?
PtG Article 14.10.2019
Will the Sports Governance Observer bring changes to world sport?
PtG Comment 14.10.2019
New standards of sports governance: When will sport join the modern world in embracing democracy?
PtG Comment 14.10.2019
Good governance – the new sport mantra
PtG Article 13.10.2019
Sport: A safe haven for athletes?
PtG Article 13.10.2019
Interview with Yuliya and Vitaly Stepanov
PtG Article 13.10.2019
Russian whistleblower: “The fight is not over yet”
PtG Article 13.10.2019
Athletes' voices: breakthrough or breakdown?
PtG Article 13.10.2019
Time’s up: Athlete power on the rise!
PtG Comment 13.10.2019
Athlete activism: An omen for sport in the 2020's?
Børn spiller fodbold
PtG Article 08.10.2019
The global challenge of growing sports

Related articles

Tine Vertommen
PtG Opinion 27.05.2024
"We should aspire to create a world where safeguarding is not just a policy but a lived reality"
Sebastian Coe greets winner
PtG Article 14.05.2024
Money for medals divides the Olympic movement
Manchester City players celebrating goal
PtG Article 02.05.2024
Thousands of players are part of MCO groups without regulations that protect their interests
Football girl with rainbow armband
PtG Opinion 26.03.2024
Practical suggestions on how sports federations can be fair to transgender athletes
Alex Krumer at Play the Game 2024
PtG Article 19.03.2024
Women's football teams should not play in white shorts if they want to win
Whitney Bragnolo at Play the Game conference
PtG Article 23.02.2024
Sports federations urged to do more to safeguard athletes
Gerke Berenschot at Play the Game conference
PtG Article 22.02.2024
Male athletes could have twice the risk of dying from cardiac issues  compared to men of similar age
Joanna Maranhão and Andrea Florence
PtG Article 19.02.2024
Sports organisations are bad at handling sexual abuse, and athletes risk retaliation for speaking out
Panel on anti-doping
PtG Article 16.02.2024
CEO of USADA: "There is a lot we could do to ease the burden on the athletes"
PtG Article 07.02.2024
Sporting bodies called out for lack of action on Palestine and Afghan women
Matthew Graham and Gigi Alford
PtG Opinion 07.02.2024
The global sport industry is out of touch, this is how we put athletes back in the game
Conference presentation
PtG Article 05.02.2024
Mali is a textbook example of how to fail victims of sexual abuse in sport
Khalida Popal
PtG Article 05.02.2024
Pay gaps, representation, or even being allowed to play - the struggle for women in football is far from over
Panel on match-fixing
PtG Article 05.02.2024
Money spent on investigating match-fixing cases would be better spent on education
Joanna Maranhao
PtG Comment 04.02.2024
Healing through compassion – my journey of navigating trauma
Victoria Silverwood
PtG Article 02.02.2024
Meet the speakers: "Ice hockey fans expect to see fights at games, but the fights are well-controlled"
Burch and Geurin
PtG Article 29.01.2024
Meet the speakers: "We found that some athletes who experienced online abuse ten years ago had still not recovered"
Zohreh Abdollahkhani
PtG Article 26.01.2024
Meet the speakers: "International sports governing bodies should ask the Iranian federations why their athletes are imprisoned"
Athlete with AI
PtG Article 04.01.2024
Perspectives on democrAItisation of sports governance: Can artificial intelligence empower athletes?
Zeinab Rezaie from Afghanistan
PtG Article 07.11.2023
The IOC has turned a blind eye to Taliban violations of the Olympic Charter for more than two years
Panel debate at SAPIS conference
PtG Article 04.10.2023
Conference showcased many examples of how athletes organise to protect and further their own interests
Runners hugging
PtG Article 20.09.2023
New SAPIS report highlights that many athletes still lack influence and points to ways forward for better athlete representation
Spanish women futsal players
PtG Article 28.08.2023
Pioneers share success stories about athlete influence at SAPIS conference
Tennis player
PtG Article 13.07.2023
Book 28 September and contribute to strengthening athlete power in sport
PtG Article 19.06.2023
SAPIS project launches good practice guide to strengthen athletes’ power in sport
PtG Comment 27.03.2023
Coe and Bach: United in history, divided by history
Alex Schwacer walking
PtG Article 16.12.2022
Race walker Alex Schwazer continues his fight against sport's jurisprudence system
Canadas ungdomslandshold i ishockey
PtG Article 29.08.2022
Sexual abuse in sport: Canada could be a world leader in developing solutions
Mikhail Zaleuski at Play the Game 2022
PtG Article 22.07.2022
Solidarity in sport: Athletes should speak up for democracy and against climate change
Rikke Rønholt.
PtG Article 30.06.2022
Without performance data for trans athletes, only principles guide the discussions
Friba Rezayee holder oplæg
PtG Article 30.06.2022
Afghanistan’s first female Olympian: IOC is funding the Taliban-controlled NOC in Kabul
PtG Article 29.06.2022
External oversight key to athlete trust in abuse and violence investigations
Panel at conference
PtG Article 29.06.2022
Reports of abuse of athletes continue to emerge across the globe
Peter Donnelly
PtG Article 28.06.2022
Peter Donnelly: Children’s elite training meets the definition of child labour
PtG Comment 27.06.2022
Sport must choose between democracy and autocracy
PtG Article 27.06.2022
Play the Game 2022 opens with a call to remove Belarussian sports officials
Boy gymnast.
PtG Article 23.06.2022
The definition of child labour in sport is still developing
Photo: GettyImages/Matt Roberts.
PtG Article 10.06.2022
New book presents urgent call to listen to athletes in modern pentathlon
Kamilia Valieva
PtG Comment 22.02.2022
Child athletes are too valuable for the Olympic system to set age limits
Krystsina Tsimanouskaya
PtG Article 30.11.2021
A vote of no confidence in the Court of Arbitration for Sport