PtG Article 05.02.2024

Session on Qatar 2022 raises tense debate about bias and bigotry in media reporting 

The first plenary session on Monday morning — aptly titled 'Biased, bigoted, boorish? The global debate on Qatar 2022' — stirred a tense discussion about the role of journalism in propagating and disseminating racist stereotypes about the Gulf state ahead of the 2022 World Cup. 

Nick Harris, the editor of Sports Intelligence, opened up the session with a speech that delved into Qatar’s misdirection in the lead-up to the World Cup, including the corrupt tactics the Gulf state used to secure the prestigious event. He also listed various examples of the promises that Qatar made but failed to keep in the aftermath of the tournament.

Harris also noted how Qatar’s obfuscation tactics helped lay a blueprint for other autocracies to follow suit. 

“Qatar wanted to control the narrative and Saudi wants to do the same,” Harris concluded. “We can see the future, we just need to look at the past.” 

Craig LaMay, a professor at Northwestern University in Qatar, added to the discussion by stressing that, while Qatar is the most progressive of all Gulf states when it comes to its media laws, it is very difficult to confirm Qatar’s claims of migrant labour reforms because of the lack of transparency.

Craig noted that journalists who attempted to report on the ground in Qatar had been arrested and that he himself had been detained twice for news gathering. 

Lack of respect or obfuscation?

The session took an interesting turn when Lars Haue-Pedersen, managing director of sports at public relations firm Burson Cohn & Wolfe (BCW), took to the stage with a plea directed at the international media to take a more “balanced” approach to reporting on Qatar. 

BCW played a role in crafting PR strategies for Qatar before the tournament, and after presenting  a question raised by a Qatari participant in a focus group — “why do [the West] dislike us?” — Haue-Pedersen asserted that Western coverage of Qatar was influenced by "post-colonial arrogance" and sprinkled with a “touch of racism.” 

“It is not respectful when Danish media call Qatar the 'desert state.' Yes, there is a lot of desert in Qatar. But no Qataris call Denmark a farmer state. Or Norway a fisherman country. They call it Norway,” he argued.

Haue-Pedersen's statements caused a stir among his fellow panellists, as well as the audience gathered in the conference room, especially as he went on to claim that, even though the West often preached inclusivity, it actually used its dedication to human rights as a means to show superiority over other countries. 

As the speakers settled into the panel debate following their individual speeches, audience members took turns voicing their displeasure with Lars’ insinuations while outlining the various ways he misdirected people during his speech. 

For instance, Steve Cockburn, the head of economic and social justice at Amnesty International who helped shape Amnesty’s campaigning on Qatar, reflected on the importance of finding the necessary nuance and balance in reporting on authoritarian regimes “but without the obfuscation that I just heard” — a reference to Lars’ lack of willingness to address Qatar’s well-documented human rights issues. 

“There were enormous, very serious and very dangerous conditions for migrant workers in Qatar that we and many other organisations documented over many years that simply cannot be dismissed in that way,” Cockburn said. 

Haue-Pedersen's remarks also drew criticism from journalists, with some directly accusing him of dishonesty in his dismissal of Western reporting on exploited migrant workers. 

Conversely, some argued that Western journalists should introspect and comprehend the reasons behind the accusations of bias being levelled against them.

“It is striking me here how people are more worried about being labelled racist than actually being anti-racist in their own practices,” Shireen Ahmed, a Muslim journalist based in Canada, said during the Q&A.

“If that is a concern for you, look at your own newsroom. Who are you surrounded by?”  

Ahmed went on to point out that there is a “growing attitude of McCarthyism” and silencing of radicalised journalists throughout the Western world, especially over the ongoing war in Gaza. 

“If you’re concerned about being labelled racist or Islamophobic, look around you,” Ahmed continued. “You have to earn the respect of people." 

 

Watch the session

Read more news from Play the Game 2024

Alex Krumer at Play the Game 2024
PtG Article 19.03.2024
Women's football teams should not play in white shorts if they want to win
Karim Zidan at Play the Game 2024
PtG Comment 27.02.2024
From Qatar to Saudi: Soul-searching in sports reporting
Whitney Bragnolo at Play the Game conference
PtG Article 23.02.2024
Sports federations urged to do more to safeguard athletes
Gerke Berenschot at Play the Game conference
PtG Article 22.02.2024
Male athletes could have twice the risk of dying from cardiac issues  compared to men of similar age
Faraz Shahlaei
PtG Article 20.02.2024
The Russian doping scandal has exposed the weaknesses in the international anti-doping structure
Joanna Maranhão and Andrea Florence
PtG Article 19.02.2024
Sports organisations are bad at handling sexual abuse, and athletes risk retaliation for speaking out
Panel on anti-doping
PtG Article 16.02.2024
CEO of USADA: "There is a lot we could do to ease the burden on the athletes"
Kristin Kloster
PtG Article 16.02.2024
IOC member: No Taliban flag at the Olympics in Paris
Zoe Flood
PtG Article 15.02.2024
Betting is a growing problem among the young populations in Africa
Panel and Steve Menary
PtG Article 07.02.2024
In-play bets and live data collection make new sports vulnerable to match-fixing
Travis Tygart
PtG Article 07.02.2024
US anti-doping director: There is an incredible need for an anti-crime agency in sport
Speaker
PtG Article 07.02.2024
Sporting bodies called out for lack of action on Palestine and Afghan women
Play the Game award winners 2024
PtG Article 07.02.2024
Investigative journalists Grit Hartmann and Nick Harris receive the Play the Game Award 2024
PtG Article 07.02.2024
Making mega-events more sustainable could just end in greenwashing
Panellists
PtG Article 06.02.2024
The German Bundesliga cut its sustainability requirements by half from 2022 to 2023
Panel on sports journalism
PtG Article 06.02.2024
Investigative sports journalism is struggling on many fronts at the same time